Thanks man its workig but it is not showing the "+" and child rows.

This is another grid I am making self relation. when I run this I am getting No Data To Display message. I have created a test table in northwid for sample project  and my datasource query is "SELECT PKID,FKID,Name,Description from Test".

Can you please check this sample code and let me now my mistakes.

 <igtbl:UltraWebGrid ID="UltraWebGrid2" runat="server" DataSourceID="WebHierarchicalDataSource2"
    Height="115px" Width="961px" DataKeyField="PKID">
    <Bands>
      <igtbl:UltraGridBand AddButtonCaption="ObjectDataSource3_DefaultView" BaseTableName="ObjectDataSource3_DefaultView"
        Key="ObjectDataSource3_DefaultView">
        <Columns>
          <igtbl:UltraGridColumn BaseColumnName="PKID" DataType="System.Int32" IsBound="True"
            Key="PKID">
            <Header Caption="PKID">
            </Header>
          </igtbl:UltraGridColumn>
          <igtbl:UltraGridColumn Key="FKID" IsBound="True" BaseColumnName="FKID">
            <Header Caption="FKID">
              <RowLayoutColumnInfo OriginX="1"></RowLayoutColumnInfo>
            </Header>
            <Footer>
              <RowLayoutColumnInfo OriginX="1"></RowLayoutColumnInfo>
            </Footer>
          </igtbl:UltraGridColumn>
          <igtbl:UltraGridColumn Key="Name" IsBound="True" BaseColumnName="Name">
            <Header Caption="Name">
              <RowLayoutColumnInfo OriginX="2"></RowLayoutColumnInfo>
            </Header>
            <Footer>
              <RowLayoutColumnInfo OriginX="2"></RowLayoutColumnInfo>
            </Footer>
          </igtbl:UltraGridColumn>
          <igtbl:UltraGridColumn Key="Description" IsBound="True" BaseColumnName="Description">
            <Header Caption="Description">
              <RowLayoutColumnInfo OriginX="3"></RowLayoutColumnInfo>
            </Header>
            <Footer>
              <RowLayoutColumnInfo OriginX="3"></RowLayoutColumnInfo>
            </Footer>
          </igtbl:UltraGridColumn>
        </Columns>
        <AddNewRow View="NotSet" Visible="NotSet">
        </AddNewRow>
      </igtbl:UltraGridBand>
      <igtbl:UltraGridBand DataKeyField="FKID" Key="FKID">
        <AddNewRow Visible="NotSet" View="NotSet">
        </AddNewRow>
        <Columns>
          <igtbl:UltraGridColumn BaseColumnName="FKID" DataType="System.Int32" IsBound="True"
            Key="FKID">
            <Header Caption="OrderID">
            </Header>
          </igtbl:UltraGridColumn>
          <igtbl:UltraGridColumn BaseColumnName="PKID" DataType="System.Int32" IsBound="True"
            Key="PKID">
            <Header Caption="PKID">
              <RowLayoutColumnInfo OriginX="2" />
            </Header>
            <Footer>
              <RowLayoutColumnInfo OriginX="2" />
            </Footer>
          </igtbl:UltraGridColumn>
          <igtbl:UltraGridColumn BaseColumnName="Description" DataType="System.Int16" IsBound="True"
            Key="Description">
            <Header Caption="Description">
              <RowLayoutColumnInfo OriginX="2" />
            </Header>
            <Footer>
              <RowLayoutColumnInfo OriginX="2" />
            </Footer>
          </igtbl:UltraGridColumn>
        </Columns>
      </igtbl:UltraGridBand>
    </Bands>
    <DisplayLayout AllowColSizingDefault="Free" AllowColumnMovingDefault="OnServer" AllowDeleteDefault="Yes"
      AutoGenerateColumns="false" AllowSortingDefault="OnClient" AllowUpdateDefault="Yes"
      BorderCollapseDefault="Separate" HeaderClickActionDefault="SortMulti" Name="UltraWebGrid1"
      RowHeightDefault="20px" RowSelectorsDefault="No" SelectTypeRowDefault="Extended"
      StationaryMargins="Header" StationaryMarginsOutlookGroupBy="True" TableLayout="Fixed"
      Version="4.00" ViewType="OutlookGroupBy">
      <FrameStyle BackColor="Window" BorderColor="InactiveCaption" BorderStyle="Solid"
        BorderWidth="1px" Font-Names="Microsoft Sans Serif" Font-Size="8.25pt" Height="115px"
        Width="961px">
      </FrameStyle>
      <Pager MinimumPagesForDisplay="2">
        <PagerStyle BackColor="LightGray" BorderStyle="Solid" BorderWidth="1px">
          <BorderDetails ColorLeft="White" ColorTop="White" WidthLeft="1px" WidthTop="1px" />
        </PagerStyle>
      </Pager>
      <EditCellStyleDefault BorderStyle="None" BorderWidth="0px">
      </EditCellStyleDefault>
      <FooterStyleDefault BackColor="LightGray" BorderStyle="Solid" BorderWidth="1px">
        <BorderDetails ColorLeft="White" ColorTop="White" WidthLeft="1px" WidthTop="1px" />
      </FooterStyleDefault>
      <HeaderStyleDefault BackColor="LightGray" BorderStyle="Solid" HorizontalAlign="Left">
        <BorderDetails ColorLeft="White" ColorTop="White" WidthLeft="1px" WidthTop="1px" />
      </HeaderStyleDefault>
      <RowStyleDefault BackColor="Window" BorderColor="Silver" BorderStyle="Solid" BorderWidth="1px"
        Font-Names="Microsoft Sans Serif" Font-Size="8.25pt">
        <Padding Left="3px" />
        <BorderDetails ColorLeft="Window" ColorTop="Window" />
      </RowStyleDefault>
      <GroupByRowStyleDefault BackColor="Control" BorderColor="Window">
      </GroupByRowStyleDefault>
      <GroupByBox>
        <BoxStyle BackColor="ActiveBorder" BorderColor="Window">
        </BoxStyle>
      </GroupByBox>
      <AddNewBox Hidden="False">
        <BoxStyle BackColor="Window" BorderColor="InactiveCaption" BorderStyle="Solid" BorderWidth="1px">
          <BorderDetails ColorLeft="White" ColorTop="White" WidthLeft="1px" WidthTop="1px" />
        </BoxStyle>
      </AddNewBox>
      <ActivationObject BorderColor="" BorderWidth="">
      </ActivationObject>
      <FilterOptionsDefault>
        <FilterDropDownStyle BackColor="White" BorderColor="Silver" BorderStyle="Solid" BorderWidth="1px"
          CustomRules="overflow:auto;" Font-Names="Verdana,Arial,Helvetica,sans-serif" Font-Size="11px"
          Height="300px" Width="200px">
          <Padding Left="2px" />
        </FilterDropDownStyle>
        <FilterHighlightRowStyle BackColor="#151C55" ForeColor="White">
        </FilterHighlightRowStyle>
        <FilterOperandDropDownStyle BackColor="White" BorderColor="Silver" BorderStyle="Solid"
          BorderWidth="1px" CustomRules="overflow:auto;" Font-Names="Verdana,Arial,Helvetica,sans-serif"
          Font-Size="11px">
          <Padding Left="2px" />
        </FilterOperandDropDownStyle>
      </FilterOptionsDefault>
    </DisplayLayout>
  </igtbl:UltraWebGrid>
  <asp:ObjectDataSource ID="ObjectDataSource3" runat="server" SelectMethod="GetAllTest"
    TypeName="TestDB"></asp:ObjectDataSource>
 
  <br />
  <ig:WebHierarchicalDataSource ID="WebHierarchicalDataSource2" runat="server">
    <DataRelations>
      <ig:DataRelation ChildColumns="FKID" ChildDataViewID="ObjectDataSource3_DefaultView"
        ParentColumns="PKID" ParentDataViewID="ObjectDataSource3_DefaultView" />
    </DataRelations>
    <DataViews>
      <ig:DataView ID="ObjectDataSource3_DefaultView" DataMember="DefaultView" DataSourceID="ObjectDataSource3" />
    </DataViews>
  </ig:WebHierarchicalDataSource>

Are you sure that your object data source is correctly setup, does the UltraGrid display any data if bound directly to ObjectDataSource3?

Yes if I bind  ObjectDataSource3  to UltraWebGrid2 grid is binding. If I bind   with SqlDataSource it is coming.

 Here my page code.

Grid:

<igtbl:UltraWebGrid ID="UltraWebGrid2" runat="server" DataSourceID="ObjectDataSource3"
    Height="115px" Width="961px" DataKeyField="PKID">

</igtbl:UltraWebGrid>

 ObjectDataSource3 :

   <asp:ObjectDataSource ID="ObjectDataSource3" runat="server" SelectMethod="GetAllTest"
    TypeName="TestDB"></asp:ObjectDataSource>

 GetAllTest function:

Public Shared Function GetAllTest() As List(Of TestInfo)

    Dim connectionString As String = System.Configuration.ConfigurationManager.ConnectionStrings("NorthwindConnectionString").ToString
    Dim queryString As String = _
     " SELECT PKID,FKID,Name,Description from Test"
    Dim lstTest As New System.Collections.Generic.List(Of TestInfo)
    Using connection As New SqlConnection(connectionString)
      Dim command As SqlCommand = connection.CreateCommand()
      command.CommandText = queryString
      Try
        connection.Open()
        Dim dr As SqlDataReader = _
         command.ExecuteReader()
        While dr.Read()
          Dim objTest As New TestInfo
          objTest.PKID = dr("PKID")
          objTest.FKID = IIf(dr("FKID") Is DBNull.Value, -9999, dr("FKID"))
          objTest.Name = dr("Name")
          objTest.Description = dr("Description")
          lstTest.Add(objTest)
        End While
        dr.Close()
      Catch ex As Exception
      End Try
    End Using
   Return lstTest

  End Function

This SqlDataSource

 <ig:WebHierarchicalDataSource ID="WebHierarchicalDataSource3" runat="server">
      <DataRelations>
        <ig:DataRelation ChildColumns="FKID" ChildDataViewID="SqlDataSource1_DefaultView"
          ParentColumns="PkID" ParentDataViewID="SqlDataSource1_DefaultView" />
      </DataRelations>
      <DataViews>
        <ig:DataView ID="SqlDataSource1_DefaultView" DataMember="DefaultView" DataSourceID="SqlDataSource1" />
      </DataViews>
    </ig:WebHierarchicalDataSource>
    <asp:SqlDataSource ID="SqlDataSource1" runat="server" ConnectionString="<%$ ConnectionStrings:NorthwindConnectionString %>"
      SelectCommand="SELECT * FROM [Test]"></asp:SqlDataSource>

You are assigning -9999 to FKID of the root items - objTest.FKID = IIf(dr("FKID") Is DBNull.Value, -9999, dr("FKID"))

That way WHDS can not determine which are the root records, you'll have to leave them DBNull (or null) in order to use self-reference relation. If FKID is of type long you can change it to Nullable long (long?) and then assign null when the value is DBNull:

objTest.FKID = IIf(dr("FKID") Is DBNull.Value, null, dr("FKID"))

Hope that helps.

 I tried with below conditions  but it is not working. 

   objTest.FKID = IIf(dr("FKID") Is DBNull.Value, Nothing, dr("FKID"))
   objTest.FKID = IIf(dr("FKID") Is DBNull.Value, DBNull.Value, dr("FKID"))
   objTest.FKID = dr("FKID")

I think -99999 is not a problem. I have binded  grid with  same logic for different tables Ticket and Ticketdeail.But I am not able to bind same table with selfrelation.

binding code is here:

WHDS

<ig:WebHierarchicalDataSource ID="WebHierarchicalDataSource1" runat="server">
    <DataRelations>
      <ig:DataRelation ChildColumns="FKTicketId" ChildDataViewID="ObjectDataSource2_DefaultView"
        ParentColumns="PKTicketId" ParentDataViewID="ObjectDataSource1_DefaultView" />
    </DataRelations>
    <DataViews>
      <ig:DataView ID="ObjectDataSource1_DefaultView" DataMember="DefaultView" DataSourceID="ObjectDataSource1" />
      <ig:DataView ID="ObjectDataSource2_DefaultView" DataMember="DefaultView" DataSourceID="ObjectDataSource2" />
    </DataViews>
  </ig:WebHierarchicalDataSource>

ObjectDataSources: 

  <asp:ObjectDataSource ID="ObjectDataSource1" runat="server" SelectMethod="GetParentOrder"
    TypeName="A1CRM.TicketDB"></asp:ObjectDataSource>
 
  <asp:ObjectDataSource ID="ObjectDataSource2" runat="server" SelectMethod="GetChildOrders"
    TypeName="A1CRM.TicketDB"></asp:ObjectDataSource>

  ObjectDataSource funtions:

   Public Shared Function GetParentOrder() As List(Of TicketInfo)
      Dim dr As IDataReader = DataHelper.ExecuteReader(ConnectionString, CommandType.Text, "select Pkticketid,TicketTitle,FKRelatedTicketId,TicketDescription from ticket where PKTicketId IN(4910,4451,4697,4345)")
      Dim lstTickets As New System.Collections.Generic.List(Of TicketInfo)
      While dr.Read()
        Dim objTicket As New TicketInfo
        objTicket.PKTicketId = dr("PKTicketId")
        objTicket.TicketTitle = dr("TicketTitle")
        objTicket.TicketDescription = dr("TicketDescription")
        objTicket.FKRelatedTicketId = IIf(dr("FKRelatedTicketId") Is DBNull.Value, Null.NullInteger, dr("FKRelatedTicketId"))
        lstTickets.Add(objTicket)
      End While
      'End If
      dr.Close()
      Return lstTickets
    End Function
    Public Shared Function GetChildOrders() As List(Of TicketDetailInfo)
      Dim dr As IDataReader = DataHelper.ExecuteReader(ConnectionString, CommandType.Text, "select Pkticketdetailid,FKTicketId ,Description  from Ticketdetail where FKTicketId in(4910,4451,4697,4345)")
      Dim lstTicketDetail As New System.Collections.Generic.List(Of TicketDetailInfo)
      While dr.Read()
        Dim objTicketDetail As New TicketDetailInfo
        objTicketDetail.PKTicketDetailId = dr("Pkticketdetailid")
        objTicketDetail.FKTicketId = dr("FKTicketId")
        objTicketDetail.Description = dr("Description")
        lstTicketDetail.Add(objTicketDetail)
      End While
      'End If
      dr.Close()
      Return lstTicketDetail
    End Function

Thaks a lot for your suggestions. I think the second approach with CustomHierarchicalDataSource will do the job.

Hi Kostas,

I'm not familiar with the IronSpeed Designer, is it possible to configure it not to call Page.DataBind()?

If that's not an option then I can suggest you two workarounds:

1. override Page.DataBind:

    public override void DataBind()
    {
        try
        {
            base.DataBind();
        }
        catch (NullReferenceException)
        {
        }
    }

2. Derive from WebHierarchicalDataSource and override DataBind to do nothing:

    public class CustomHierarchicalDataSource : WebHierarchicalDataSource
    {
        public override void DataBind()
        {
           
        }
    }

Then use CustomHierarchicalDataSource instead of WebHierarchicalDataSource.

Hope that helps for now. We are going to fix that in future versions and hotfixes of the control.

Hi, I have read all previous posts and i think i face the same issue with WebHierarchicalDataSource.

I have a self referencing data table in SqlServer 2005. I placed an SqlDataSource, a HierarchicalDataSource and an UltraWebMenu in an empty page. Everything works fine. The problem appears when i call this.DataBind() in the page load event. Then page childcontrols databinding is performed in a specific order. When the HierarchicalDataSource.DataBind() is called a null reference exception is thrown. If instead of this.DataBind(), when i call UltraWebMenu.DataBind() everything works fine again.

The reason this is an issue for me is because i use IronSpeed Designer for the project i currently work on. ISD internally calls Page.DataBind() in the Page.OnLoad event. Is there a workaround to this?

 I am currently using 8.3.20083.2021 version of asp .net controls.

Thanks in advance, Kostas.

 I have posted issue on Infragistics. Issue id:CAS-11530-1G9RQT.

I have attached the sample project also can you fix that sample project.

 Null.NullInteger is -99999